[Review] Good Thing – i-dle

After rebranding from (G)I-DLE to i-dle earlier this month and pre-releasing the single Girlfriend, i-dle is officially back with their 8th mini-album, We Are. Leading the mini-album is the single Good Thing. It is their first release since July 2024’s Klaxon and their 7th mini-album, I SWAY.

To me, Good Thing is an underbaked version of their top hits. The instrumental behind Good Thing has so much potential and is its best asset, with the synth work and 8-bit sounding reminiscent of second-generation KPOP. The infusion of rock elements was a great way to make Good Thing feel very much in i-dle’s wheelhouse, but I wished the song explored more of this. Perhaps make the song even more electrifying. But it is ultimately the song’s hooks that don’t offer much in terms of robustness and dynamism that let Good Thing down. I liked how they carried their usual sassy feel into the chorus, but the hooks themselves didn’t spark any excitement. Also, “I heard your good thing” isn’t too great of a line. Aside from that, the rest of Good Thing is okay. Their rapping and vocals were nice. YUQI’s rap in the second verse is solid, while the pre-choruses were strong segments from the vocalists. While I don’t usually agree with autotune, I think it fits in with the instrumental of Good Thing and gives off a good effect. Overall, Good Thing has promise but undelivers when it matters the most.

The music video for Good Thing was a blast to watch. While I am not entirely sure what message the group is trying to say through their lyrics, the mix of constant fighting and then vibing with one another actually makes for a fun video. My favourite part involves MIYEON on the train, where she gets her hair pulled by MINNIE and pushes YUQI off the train. As to what this could possibly mean, my best guess (and I want to emphasise that this is a guess since I don’t understand the lyrics) is that the “constant fighting and then vibing with one another” dynamic represents their toxic relationship with a former lover, with the lyrics coming off as sarcastic and making fun of their past lover.

The choreography for this comeback is fantastic. Quite sure I have mentioned this about them in the past, but I love how their routines exude confidence, boldness and sexiness. They are a powerful group, and their choreographies have consistently shown this. The only part that I felt could be cleaner and smoother is the start of the instrumental break at the end.

Song – 7.5/10
Music Video – 9/10
Performance – 9/10
Overall Rating – 8.3/10