BLACKPINK And TWICE’s Recent Releases Spark Heated Debate

The new tracks couldn’t be moe different from each other.

A viral post on Korean online forum Pann is stirring up major debate among K-Pop fans after asking a simple but controversial question: “Who has the better song: BLACKPINK or TWICE?”

The post — which has gained over 150 upvotes and 204 downvotes— invited users to vote by liking the post for BLACKPINK or disliking it for TWICE, sparking a wave of passionate responses.

| @BLACKPINK/X (formerly known as Twitter)

The debate centers around BLACKPINK’s latest release “JUMP” and TWICE’s summer track “THIS IS FOR.” While both songs mark a return from the top third-generation girl groups, their concepts and receptions couldn’t be more different.

| JYP Entertainment

BLACKPINK’s “JUMP” is a high-energy, bass-heavy track that blends the group’s signature sound with new club-like music. The music video sparked quite the controversy and received mixed reactions at first. Some netizens were also unsure of the song’s direction, but later admitted the song was more addictive than expected.

On the other hand, TWICE’s “THIS IS FOR” leans into a more traditional pop sound with a strong empowering message behind it. Starkly different from “JUMP” the TWICE tracks appeals more to fans who like simpler pop music. While it hasn’t made as much noise on the charts, some listeners have praised its message and energetic choreography.

As expected, fans of each group took to the comments. While most remained friendly, the viral post triggered some heated reactions.

| Pann

• “The best 3rd-gen girl group.”
• “At first I wasn’t sure if BLACKPINK’s MV was it, lol, but it’s actually kind of fun.”
• “Both are good.”
• “I watched both MVs. I personally prefer TWICE’s song, but despite the negative reactions BLACKPINK got at first, their song is actually fun and easy to listen to (especially Jisoo’s chorus, it stuck with me). TWICE’s MV is pretty and safe, BLACKPINK’s is fresh and hip. In the end, both are good.”
• “Both are great. BLACKPINK’s song is more addictive, while TWICE’s suits the summer vibe better. Each has its own charm.”
• “Isn’t it disrespectful to even compare BLACKPINK to chart-out TWICE? You damn geezers.”